Woman Hollering Creek by Sandra Cisneros
Woman Hollering Creek by Sandra Cisneros was first published in her collection of short stories, ‘Woman Hollering Creek and Other Stories in 1991. I chose these stories because Cisneros has mixed so many facts of life on life in Mexico. The stories revolves much around the poor Latin women and the kind of life that they live is very touching ;it makes one aware that leading a good life should not be taken for granted. The stories make one to compromise with the characters. The writer draws heavily from her childhood experience and ethnic origin. Cisneros was born in 1954 and creates characters who are typically Spanish and who are set apart from the American culture. She puts an emphasis on dialogue and sensory imagery over the long-established narrative structures.Wyatt (2010) commentary on the collection of short stories by Cisneros aided me in understanding the stories.
Woman Hollering Creek Analysis Essay
The stories cover and give voice to the effervescent and diverse life on both sides of the Mexican borders.In the stories Cisneros talks of a little girl revealing secrets in a childlike manner, she also says that a witch flied at down over their small town, commentaries which Wyatt has used in her commentaries. These are some of the statement used by the writer to describe how life was different in the two sides of the border. The picture that Wyatt creates helps the reader in understanding the colorful life on the Texas/Mexico border. The commentary also reveals the nature of women in the short stories and is full of wholesome discovery; they are also filled with moments of countless and intimate wisdom. In the stories the family ties are very strong; all members of any family are present.
For instance Cisneros talks of cousins, grandparents, aunts, uncles, aunts and cousins among others. The commentary has helped in understanding that the stories are romantic dreams of a young girl who can’t wait to get away from a stifling small town life; the girl soon discovers that life is no different on the other side of the border. The writer of the stories has a very sensitive eye because she notes and reveals secrets and dreams of the characters in the stories. She also has a sense of humor and love for the people whom she is close to and describes them passionately. Wyatt commentary on the stories by Cisneros allows one to understand the life on both sides of the Mexican borders.
Payant (1999) has also made some commentaries on the short stories by Sandra Cisneros. She talks of the themes that have been brought out in the novel. To her the writer addresses the themes of domestic abuse, rape, Misogyny and limitations of traditional gender roles in the women characters. She argued that the characters in the stories are aware of the soul deadening restrictions of family and cultural expectation as they struggle to address and take charge of their own destinies. This commentary helps a reader to gain the insight of the major subject matter that the writer has tackled. The characters especially women live in complete poverty and cultural suppression, the stories also revolve around the search for self identity. The women in the stories try to escape their fate by becoming educated and self expression; by doing this they escape the patriarchal limits of their culture. The commentators examines the role that the American popular culture and the mythical figures in the story that enables one to have a deep insight of the stories.
The stories follow a structure and theme pattern which is similar to that of Cisneros first collection of short fiction in 1983. Payant deems the dialogue as overly simple and asserts that her repeated depiction of male violence toward women is an unflattering view of Hispanic life. The mythical and innovative techniques have been widely appreciated to Payant. This is because her concentration on the cultural imperialism and issues of women has a universal appeal and it is these features that strike realism and dynamic portrayal. This book by Cisneros is a remarkable and persuasive work of fiction and this is the second reason I chose to review commentaries on this book and also write on it.
The third commentary is by Rodriguez and Pilar (1990). The two interviewed the writer Sandra Cisneros on the solitary fate of being a Mexican woman. This commentary revealed that Cisneros was an only daughter in a family of seven children. She talked on how she felt like she had seven fathers because her brothers were always attempting to control her and expected her to take up the role of a traditional female role. She talks of how she felt homeless and displaced and how she retreated inside herself.
This interview enables one to understand that the point of view from which Cisnero was portraying her characters. Her rights as a woman were suppressed and thus the challenges faced by Cisneros characters because of their gender cannot be comprehended in isolation of the culture. The culture suppressed the women’s rights since it laid out how women and men were supposed to behave. Cisneros portrays the character of Chicanas as a girl tackling the deeply rooted patriarchal values of the Mexicans. The fathers and the whole community apply pressure on Chicanas to conform to a description of womanhood that is very narrow and also to assume a subservient position to men. Cisneros depicts how Chicanas and many other women from other parts of the world internalize norms that suppress them from a very young age. The girls learn to internalize these norms through informal education by the members of the family and also popular culture.
Cisneros tackles the issue of female sexuality and she shows the negative side of men where they exert control over women; they do this by exploring the gap between representations that are idealized in popular culture and real sexual incidences of women. These stories are meant to represent women who are victims of male patriarchy. My thoughts after reading the stories was that Cisneros wanted the women readers to take note of the stereotypes that suppress them and which they are supposed to conform to and reject them as she did. She encourages them to enjoy their sexuality.